The vast majority of products that we find in stores are transported on a pallet at some point. Pallets are a key component of modern logistical processes and packaging systems. But what types of pallets exist today and how are they best geared to the products that need to be transported? How relevant is prevention in this field? And what are the latest trends? The current state of affairs is discussed below.
Pallets are transport plates used for many years to store and carry goods. The most common pallet size in use in Europe is the 80 x 120 cm format. This standardized size has fostered the existence of various reusable pallet systems in which pallets are exchanged between companies. However, many other formats also currently exist.
Wood, plastic, metal, etc.
Approximately 86% of reusable pallets are made of wood. The remainder is made of plastic (4%), chipboard (3%), or metal (3%). In the case of disposable pallets, the share of wood is 70%. ‘One of the benefits of wood pallets is that they are easy to recycle,’ states Maxence Wittebolle, General Manager of the Belgian Packaging Institute. ‘They can also be easily repaired if they are damaged. This is not the case with plastic pallets for instance. The latter, however, are more hygienic because they resist fungus. That is why they are frequently used in the food sector, as well as the chemical and pharmaceutical sectors. Some types of plastic pallet materials integrate synthetic foam in order to make them lighter.’
As their name indicates, presswood pallets are made from wood residue pressed into shape under high pressure. Thanks to their pre-shaped form, they can be stacked very efficiently. As a result, they require less storage space and limit storage costs. Metal pallets are also used—primarily in the metallurgical industry—for the transportation of heavy objects and machine components.
As expected, metal pallets are the ones with the longest lifetime.
Good to remember
- Pallets must be chosen according to the product they are to transport as well as the primary and/or secondary packaging and means of transport.
- Tests can indicate whether a pallet is properly designed and built to meet the various functions it must fulfill.
- Companies continuously strive to optimize pallet construction materials as well as the loading pattern of the products they carry.
Pallets are pillars of the logistical process
‘A pallet must be seen as a fully-fledged component of a packaging system,’ adds Wittebolle. ‘The type and size of a pallet must be chosen according to the transported product and the primary and/or secondary packaging used. The conditions of transport and the various functions throughout the logistical process must also be considered. A badly chosen pallet at the bottom can entail considerable damage during transport as well as costly bills for companies, even though they may have chosen suitable packaging.’
The type and size of a pallet must be adapted to the product in order to avoid damage during transport.
From load capacity to moisture-proofing
‘Every situation is different; there is no universal solution,’ stresses Wittebolle. ‘That is why we always test pallets to ensure that they are sufficiently adapted to the product and the packaging that they must carry.’ All tests at the Belgian Packaging Institute are carried out in line with the ISO 8611 reference standard.
This enables the precise calculation of the load capacity of the pallets, among other things. The Belgian Packaging Institute also executes bending tests, forklift tests, compression tests, and stacking tests.
Moisture and temperature resistance also play an important role. A pallet that is perfectly suitable for use in Europe, for instance, may not necessarily be appropriate for warm and humid countries such as India and China. ‘For example, we recommend that companies avoid storing wooden pallets outdoors. Wood absorbs humidity, which can substantially weaken the load bearing capacity and encourage the growth of unwanted fungus,’ says Wittebolle. ‘In the case of products for which fungus must be avoided, presswood pallets are an interesting option. Because these are produced at high pressure, the necessity of chemical fumigation is eliminated.’
A pallet that is perfectly suitable for use in Europe is not necessarily appropriate for warm and humid countries such as India and China.
Disposable pallets: not necessarily lost
Today, companies can choose either disposable or reusable pallets. The definitions for both are unequivocally established by federal authorities and can be viewed on www.ivcie.be.
Disposable pallets are often viewed as waste once they have been unloaded at the customer’s premises or the site of a logistical services supplier. However, these pallets are not necessarily lost.
Today, numerous specialized companies collect used pallets. Depending on the quality, type, and dimensions of the pallets, these companies can repair them and resell them. This process is called reconditioning.
If the pallets cannot be repaired, or if their specific shape or dimensions makes it impossible to find a new application for them, they can be recycled. Depending on their material, the pallets can be ground up, dismantled, or melted to serve as raw material for new products. The disposable pallets then start a new life in another application. This process is referred to as recycling. The majority of the wood packaging that is declared in the VAL-I-PAC system is comprised of pallets. Each year, more than 105,000 tons of wood pallets are recycled.
Reusable pallets in all types and sizes
Two types of reusable pallet systems currently exist: closed and open.
In closed system, a company buys and manages its own pallets. The company must see to it that the used pallets are always returned and takes care of their management, maintenance, and repair.
In an open or pooling system, pallets are shared among several companies. Management of the system is generally in the hands of specialized companies such as CHEP, LPR, and PRS. The benefit of these pooling systems is that users do not need to answer for the pallets themselves nor do they need to worry about stocks, follow-up, or maintenance. You can read more about this system in the CHEP testimonial.
The Epal system is a pooling system for the reuse of Europallets. Every time a loaded pallet is delivered, an empty pallet – or a credit note – is handed in or credited to the carrier. It is not however part of an overall management system.
Regional and other limitations
The pallets used in pooling systems are often strictly standardized. Indeed, they must be usable by multiple companies. In some cases, this can be a drawback. Companies that require pallets with specific dimensions or characteristics must therefore rely on their own pallets.
In practice, the pooling of pallets is almost always limited to welldefined areas, even though some pooling systems are available worldwide. In various parts of the world—such as America, the Far East, or in specific local regions—pallets have different dimensions or characteristics. In most cases, pooling will therefore only be possible within certain well-defined areas and almost never between continents.
Prevention - caution is required
In order to optimize the use of pallets, companies often aim to make them lighter or try to place more products on a single pallet.
This practice, however, requires caution. ‘Saving on transport packaging can have substantial economic and environmental consequences; consider the potential product losses and the cleaning of spoilt containers in the event of a faulty pallet,’ observes Wittebolle. ‘We therefore do not recommend the use of pallets that are too light when exporting to distant countries. They do not offer sufficient strength to resist the many movements that containers undergo at sea.
As a result, there is a risk of them collapsing, entailing a whole string of risks and consequences.’
New materials, new alternatives
‘A recent but limited trend is the development of paper pallets (see also the IKEA testimonial). The benefit of these cardboard pallets is that they are relatively easy to customize,’ notes Wittebolle. ‘Some distributors even use them as displays in their stores. These pallets are obviously light but this can be a drawback in terms of robustness. In addition, they are less resistant to humidity.’
Another trend is the development of alternative handling systems to avoid the use of pallets altogether. The so-called slip sheets, for instance, are sheets that are placed underneath loads to prevent goods from sliding during transport. Another example is loading ledges, i.e. support plates that can be placed on various sides of a transport load. The benefit of these systems is that they enable the optimal use of space inside a truck. The drawback is that they require other equipment for loading and unloading. ‘A great deal of optimization still remains possible in this respect,’ concludes Wittebolle.
For additional information
- The Belgian Packaging Institute promotes the rational use of packaging. It provides services to public authorities and companies in the areas of legislation, information, and education. www.ibebvi.be
- CHEP pooling system. www.chep.com
- LPR pooling system. www.lpr.eu
- Pallet Return System (PRS pooling system). www.palletreturnsystem.com
- Europallet system. www.epal-pallets.org
Making the most of the available space within trucks
Moving products with a minimum of waste and at the least possible cost to the environment and the company – that is what optimizing transport packaging is all about. The choice of transport packaging material as well as how the products are loaded into the truck all play important roles. According to the Packaging Centre of the XIOS Institute in Limburg, Belgium, there is still plenty of room for improvement.
’Typical problem areas are the ever heavier pallet loads, as well as products that either extend past the edge of the pallet or that leave too much margin between the products and the edges of a pallet,’ observes Philip De Schepper, Technical Manager at the Packaging Centre. ‘We also encounter a lot of over-packaging. Understandably, companies often prefer to use excess packaging rather than risk product loss. That being said, this is clearly better than not enough packaging. In many cases, however, it is easy to achieve savings without increasing the risk of damage.’
Ensure piling strength
The quest for optimal transport packaging depends on each individual company and is strongly linked to the processes within a specific company. In addition, primary, secondary, and tertiary packaging strongly influence each other. For instance, the size of cardboard packaging is best chosen as a function of its possibilities for palletization. This is the only approach that leads to the optimal filling of both the pallet and the truck.
‘It is also essential to avoid products sticking out past the edge of a pallet or with excessive inner margins between the load and the edges of the pallet,’ adds De Schepper. ‘When this occurs, there is a considerable impact on both the piling strength and stability. When cardboard boxes containing products extend past the edges of a pallet, they lose a large part of their support, substantially increasing the risk of toppling and product damage.’ For some loads, it is therefore best to pile the boxes like bricks in a wall. That is the best way to ensure sufficient strength and stability.
Overloading a pallet is not ideal either. ‘We encourage companies to load pallets in an optimal configuration; this is not the same as loading them to the maximum,’ points out De Schepper. ‘We strongly advise, for example, that there should not be any empty spaces between products and that there should be as little room as possible between the load and the edges of a pallet. Experience has taught us that minimum room is ideal so as to avoid having products sticking out of a pallet and prevent load movement.’
Software helps improve palletizing
A growing number of companies use palletization software to calculate how a pallet and a truck can be optimally loaded. This employs a large number of criteria—the product, the packaging, the length and type of transport, et cetera. The software indicates which factors influence the palletization scheme and how these factors can be optimized one by one
‘Many companies already use such software tools yet still experience problems. This often has to do with the fact that not all parameters are known or taken into account. Factors such as temperature, humidity, and transport distance are often overlooked,’ points out Gudrun Nowicki, Project Engineer at the Packaging Centre. ‘We can help companies make better use of their software, highlight where the issues are, or make the calculations for them.’
De plus en plus d’entreprises recourent à un logiciel de palettisation pour calculer comment charger au mieux les palettes et les camions. Le programme intègre toute une série de critères (produit, emballage, durée, type de transport, etc.) et indique les facteurs influençant le schéma de palettisation et la façon d’optimiser chacun d’eux. ”De nombreuses entreprises utilisent déjà de tels logiciels, mais continuent de rencontrer des problèmes étant donné que tous les paramètres ne sont pas connus et ne sont donc pas pris en compte.
Ainsi, des facteurs comme la température, le taux d’humidité et la distance de transport sont parfois négligés”, note Gudrun Nowicki, ingénieur de projet auprès du Centre de l’emballage. ”Nous aidons les entreprises à utiliser adéquatement un tel logiciel, leur indiquons où se situent les problèmes, ou effectuons les calculs pour eux. ”
Good to remember
- Various product and transport related parameters must be taken into account in order to optimize transport packaging.
- Palletization software can help companies in this respect.
- Optimal transport packaging and palletization begins at the design phase of the product as well as its packaging.
Testing the quality of pallets
It is relatively easy to test the quality of a pallet load. ‘Companies can call upon our Packaging Centre for such tests,’ adds Nowicki. ‘Vibration tests, for instance, are essential to verify whether the goods and/or the packaging do not break, or to make sure that the products won’t move or fall while inside the vehicle, which complicates unloading. We use a large vibration table to check this. We also simulate changes in temperature and humidity in order to measure their influence. All of these tests can be carried out on a broad array of secondary and tertiary packaging.’
Palletization software employs numerous criteria to calculate and optimize the stacking pattern, height, and location of boxes.
Include transport packaging in the design stage
‘Few companies consider factors involved in transport packaging during the development stage of their product and its packaging,’ explains Nowicki. ‘However, doing so can avoid a great deal of over-packaging, given the fact that the various levels of packaging strongly influence each other. The specifications and materials of the secondary and tertiary packaging are important points of focus, as is their role throughout the logistical process – including handling and storage.
Points to pay attention to :
- Plan extra strengthening under the lower pallets when stacking loaded pallets.
- Ensure that the cling film used to stabilize the load on a pallet is sufficiently strong. Cling films lose a great deal of their tension and holding power at high temperatures. Avoid letting cling film wrapped pallets stand in the sun too long.
- Consider the time and the distance over which the products must be transported. Transport packaging for European-wide shipping must be twice as strong on average as packaging for internal transport within Belgium. Transport packaging that is sent overseas must be up to seven times stronger.
For additional informational
- The XIOS Packaging Centre in Limburg, Belgium, carries out research on many types of packaging. In addition, this research institution also helps companies solve packaging problems and develop new packaging solutions. Packaging Centre (VerpakkingsCentrum) XIOS Hogeschool Limburg Universitaire Campus, Agoralaan, bâtiment H 3590 Diepenbeek www.verpakkingscentrum.be
Free packaging diagnose
XIOS offers a tailored packaging diagnosis in collaboration with Fost Plus and VAL-I-PAC. An expert visits your company for one day and then prepares a report with observations and recommendations. The report contains both structural modifications for the long term and quick wins enabling companies to rapidly achieve savings.